Pay Bills

Pay your bill online anytime directly at your company’s website. You can also find your company’s number here to make a credit/debit payment over the phone.

CompanyPhone NumberOnline
NATIONWIDE1-800-282-1446Nationwide Online
HARTFORD1-866-574-4833Hartford Online
DONEGAL1-800-877-9006Donegal Online
STATE AUTO1- 800-766-1853State Auto Online
PROGRESSIVE1-800-776-4737Progressive Online
OHIO MUTUAL1-888-895-7725Ohio Mutual Online
FOREMOST1-800-527-3907Foremost Online
HASTINGS MUTUAL1-800-926-3168Hastings Mutual Online
ALLSTATE1-800-ALLSTATEAllstate Online
TRAVELERS1-800-252-4633Travelers Online
PEKIN1-888-735-4611Pekin Online

You may also call our office during business hours and we will be glad to take a credit/debit card payment over the phone from you. (Provided your company allows it.)

Call us at: (937) 746-1221
Or our toll free number: 1-888-746-1221

Our office is open for calls Mon-Sat from 9 to 5
Closed daily from Noon to 1 for Lunch

We Rank Best In State!

Kristopher Miller
I have known Clint and his family since back when they was Central Insurance when my cousin Amy used to work there they’ve always been good to us I’ve always been like a family to us very well spoken always reaching out for help if you need I give 5 stars well recommend 👍👍
Nikki Richmond
Amazing service and always there when we have needed them!!!! Been with Shop Once for 13/14 years now!! Clint and the crew has always provided top notch service!
Gary Cheesman
My insurance company just saved me money on my insurance woohoo
Evan Renner
Our experience so far has been that this agency has been attentive to our needs, and worked in a timely and effective manner at getting things taken care of. We were able to easily make changes to our policy, and they helped to educate and guide us along the way. I also appreciate that their phones are answered by a human that was helpful in directing me to the right person.
Very professional!
Joshua McKinney
Fantastic customer service, and a caring staff. Clint and his team helped me navigate my policy options and answered any questions I had.
Christopher McCall
Very nice gentleman! Answered all my questions, and got me insured right away!
John Meeks
These guys are great. Never had problems and very helpful!
Sherina Lollar
Outstanding service! I will not ever change my insurance company